Government education overeach, dicey indeed

2 comments

Posted on 23rd February 2010 by Judy Breck in Obamaschool | Politics | Schools we now have

, ,

In an ideas piece in Politico this morning, the author Nia-Malika Henderson speculates that the Obama education proposals will get broad support. She concludes her article with this quotation from Republican strategist Rich Galen:

“Even if you are a little dicey on it as a Republican because you are worried about government overreach with education, you have to think long and hard about the fact that you voted against kids’ education.”

With apologies to Mr. Galen, his response is Pavlovian: We have been programmed for decades to think throwing money at government (“public”) schooling somehow improves our kids’ education. That education has only gotten worse and worse over those decades.

Now along comes the Obama-led takeover / makeover of America into European-like socialism. The worst of the education piece is it further makes certain an underclass will be formed by the schools — now one that is dependent on and defined by the federal government.

Some thoughts on ending the underclass Obamaschool would perpetuate, and how handschooling is a potent protection of the right and ability of individual kids to learn:

Handschooling will — at last — break each individual child’s learning free to go beyond the control of education establishments. Sound scary? Nothing scares me more about the future than limiting yet another young generation to the analog, tradition-dominated, doling out of a bit of this knowledge and a bit of that knowledge by some remote priesthood (pedagogical, secular, ideological, political, — yes and/or religious too).

We should all be very afraid of education policy reigning from far away. The range of control and chaos these distant pedagogues cause is wide. There is the sort that pumps gushes of money into celebrating mediocrity which perpetuates an underclass the nanny standard setters can count on to keep them in power. There are tyrannies that nurture hatred and spawn fanaticism in the young, even to the horror of blowing people up. Settling for inferior, and even destructive, education for other people’s children is all too easy when those children are in other people’s neighborhoods and towns and beyond.

While we nurture our children up close, we should strive for equal opportunity to learn for each child. Serendipitously, wonderfully — in the 21st century there is a brand new way to do just that! Handschooling has almost suddenly opened the way for every youngster across the world to learn from a global commons of that is known by humankind.

Obama’s Race to the Top locks in a diploma bell curve

1 comment

Posted on 7th February 2010 by Judy Breck in Equality | Schools we now have

, , , , , ,


The Race to the Top is granting $4 billion American taxpayer dollars to the states for “reforming” public schools. The program’s webpage at Ed.gov gives this bottom line explanation:

Race to the Top winners will help trail-blaze effective reforms and provide examples for States and local school districts throughout the country to follow as they too are hard at work on reforms that can transform our schools for decades to come.

For 21st century education reforming education around public schools locks in a bell curve for schooling that makes diplomas of unequal value. One of the four specific areas in Race for the Top is: Turning around our lowest-achieving schools. The illustration above shows why doing so traps the students in these schools at the lower end of a bell curve of diploma value. The school on the low end of the bell curve is Columbus High School in the Bronx, New York. Columbus is now scheduled to be closed because it is failing. Realistically, turning it around would move the value of its diploma up the downside of the bell curve. The Race to the Top sort of thinking will see such movement as a victory, yet the Columbus students will remain in a far inferior school by comparison to schools like Jefferson, ranked number one US high school for 2010. The Jefferson diploma will remain far more valuable to a student who earns it than the Columbus diploma. That system is unfair.

There is a better way: replace the bell curve with the long tail

The internet is a power law network where the long tail can replace the bell curve. We should not allow public education to persist in bell curve school-ranking methods that perpetuate an underclass. Handschooling a power law tool; more on that point here soon.

As explained in a recent handschooling.com post, online testing open to all would give a Columbus student a way to complete with Jefferson students. What is now coming out of ed.gov is a race a bit of the way up the downside of the public school bell curve — at a price tag of $4 billion. Has Congress approved this expenditure?

EQUALITY

0 comments

Posted on 22nd January 2010 by Judy Breck in Uncategorized

My mobile does not prejudge me


No more underclass

Schooling at an analog school is NEVER equal:
Students are graded: from A+ to A to B and down to F for failing.
Some students are teacher’s pets.
Other students are unpopular.
Minority students are expected not to do well.
Students in some schools have better books and teachers.

Handschooling is ALWAYS equal.
The device a student uses does not know who the person is.
Exactly the same internet is out there for every handschooler.

Long tail learning is facilitated by handschooling

The power law, long tail internet knowledge emergence frees students and diplomas from bell curve inequalities.

ABOUT

3 comments

Posted on 20th January 2010 by Judy Breck in Uncategorized

An explanation of this blog/website from Judy Breck:

The ideas I am interfacing at handschooling.com represent a lifetime of thinking and working in education — complemented by a degree in political science and a lot of political campaign experience. I learned political ropes by staffing six Texas elections and two national Presidential campaigns. I have also staffed six White House education symposia. Here I am putting ideas out for consideration and urging you to do something about them politically — both locally and nationally. It is also crucial that our citizenry take hold of education in local communities. Education is primarily socialized; it is government education. The effect is locking young people into classes that are divided by how much they know.

The problems and solutions I write about are mostly couched in terms of the United States, but they are equally true across the world. If you are a foreign reader, you will know that is so. Education is socialized, nationalized, state-run — whatever you want to call it — almost everywhere. I will show here that the individual student mobile web browser and the relocation online of the knowledge education is supposed to convey to youngsters has made it possible to individualize learning.

For thirty years I have worked with students in New York City public schools. I can no longer temper my anger at how government education prejudges kids and disqualifies them to race for the top in a free society like America used to be. The hope for free societies across the world is dim indeed when their new generations are educated by their governments.

The Obama administration has begun powerful moves to make state public education into national government education. This will lock in the factors that trap minority kids into an underclass — which, BTW, is a dependency that leads to voting for socialism. The effects will not be limited to the minority students whom Obama is using for an excuse to control the schools from Washington. Federal influence on subject standards is underway as money awarded to states rides on compliance. Are we really going to allow bureaucrats to decide what every American student is taught about our nation’s history — how much and which events? Will we let them limit the study of sciences to standard curricula limited by the bell curve limit of what all can learn — instead of letting individual youngsters follow their gifts with their curiosity among the bountiful networks of authoritative science online? Will we let Washington decide?

Education needs to be reborn like a phoenix, and 5 areas in which you could help it happen:

My enthusiasm for how handschooling can individualize learning and push kids toward their talents is as strong as my anger. There is good news that can squelch the bad news: let’s do it!

I am working on an e-book manifest to describe Liberated Learning: Leaving the bell curve for the long tail in our connected age. Handschooling.com is also a work in progress. Time is short. The Obama education juggernaut must be halted. Stay tune here for more.

This post:  outlines the structure I am putting into place on Handschooling.com. Everything is  under construction, but a lot of what bloggers call “pillar content” is in growing — content that sets out the big, general ideas for a blog.

SOME HANDSCHOOLING GOALS: Advocate how to make education really better in these 2 ways:

1) See too it that every individual student across the world has a mobile device connected to the internet that he and she can use it to learn from the global online knowledge commons.

2) Bring to the forefront the networking online commons, making this superior knowledge more findable and mobile friendly — so that it pushes learning away from standardized knowledge delivered in disconnected little curriculum boxes via government education.

THE SECTIONS IN WHICH THESE SUBJECTS ARE PRESENTED:
(For each of these five sections, I am developing action points available online and in an ebook.)

Mobiles: Link one mind what is known — instead of homogenizing each kid into a continuously lowering grade standard.

Findability, realizing the commons A global golden age of learning is dawning because networks form the platform of the online knowledge commons, where, as Ted Stevens said “Everything is deeply intertwingled. In an important sense there are no ’subjects’ at all; there is only all knowledge, since the cross-connections among the myriad topics of this world simply cannot be divided up neatly.” The government education that now controls most schools pays billions for curricula, textbooks, and standards that break the cross-connections and dumb down learning. Handschooling lets the student travel the intertwingularity.

Commons achieves equality that schooling never can or will achieve because handschooling is based on the individual student. The commons does not have pre-conceptions of individuals who connect to it to learn, as do teachers to whom are assigned a class of children in failing or marginal schools. The mobile in a student’s pocket has no idea whether it is owned by a prep school student, a slum dog, or a girl whose religion does not permit her to attend school: owning a mobile levels the playing field.

Next: peeks at new cool education This section will showcase exciting learnodes from the global commons, and review ideas from other sectors that could be cool new innovations for education.

Nurture: Keeping upbringing local. Opponents of using internet knowledge wrongly react that teaching and minding our children will somehow move to a distant internet if the internet is used to connect to knowledge. The opposite is true, especially as government education is trying to assume more and more control over what is taught and what local schools are funded.

Politics: Liberty and learning. Citizen demand of their politicians that handschooling be implemented will liberate the future thinking of all children across the planet, and prepare their generation to remake the world toward global liberty and peace.